Current:Home > InvestGun applicants in New York will have to submit their social accounts for review -MacroWatch
Gun applicants in New York will have to submit their social accounts for review
View
Date:2025-04-12 13:43:18
ALBANY, N.Y. — As missed warning signs pile up in investigations of mass killings, New York state is rolling out a novel strategy to screen applicants for gun permits. People seeking to carry concealed handguns will be required to hand over their social media accounts for a review of their "character and conduct."
It's an approach applauded by many Democrats and national gun control advocacy groups, but some experts have raised questions about how the law will be enforced and address free speech concerns.
Some of the local officials who will be tasked with reviewing the social media content also are asking whether they'll have the resources and, in some cases, whether the law is even constitutional.
Sheriffs haven't received additional money or staffing to handle a new application process, said Peter Kehoe, the executive director of the New York Sheriffs' Association. The law, he asserted, infringes on Second Amendment rights, and while applicants must list their social media accounts, he doesn't think local officials will necessarily look at them.
"I don't think we would do that," Kehoe said. "I think it would be a constitutional invasion of privacy."
The new requirement, which takes effect in September, was included in a law passed last week that sought to preserve some limits on firearms after the Supreme Court ruled that most people have a right to carry a handgun for personal protection. It was signed by Gov. Kathy Hochul, a Democrat, who noted shooters sometimes telegraph their intent to hurt others.
Increasingly, young men have gone online to drop hints of what's to come before executing a mass killing, including the gunman who killed 19 children and two teachers at an Uvalde, Texas, elementary school.
Officials will scour social accounts for statements suggesting dangerous behavior
Under the law, applicants have to provide local officials with a list of current and former social media accounts from the previous three years. It will be up to local sheriff's staff, judges or country clerks to scroll through those profiles as they check whether applicants have made statements suggesting dangerous behavior.
The law also will require applicants to undergo hours of safety training, prove they're proficient at shooting, provide four character references and sit for in-person interviews.
The law reflects how the Supreme Court ruling has shifted responsibility to states for vetting those who carry firearms in public, said Tanya Schardt, senior counsel and director of state and federal policy for gun control advocacy organization Brady.
Her group said it was not aware of any other states requiring gun permit applicants to submit social media profiles.
The new approach, however, comes amid growing debate over the policing of social media posts and a legacy of unwarranted surveillance of Black and brown communities.
"The question should be: Can we do this in an anti-racist way that does not create another set of violence, which is the state violence that happens through surveillance?" said University of Pennsylvania social policy, communications and medicine professor Desmond Upton Patton, who also founded SAFElab, a research initiative studying violence involving youths of color.
Meanwhile, gun rights advocates are blasting the law.
"You're also going to have to tell them your social media accounts because New York wants to thoroughly investigate you to figure out if you're some of those dangerous law-abiding citizens who are taking the country by storm and causing crime to skyrocket," Jared Yanis, host of the YouTube channel Guns & Gadgets, says in a widely viewed video on the new law. "What have we come to?"
Hochul, who also has tasked state police with routing out extremism online, didn't immediately respond to a list of questions about the social media requirement, including how the state will address free speech and privacy concerns.
Some experts wonder how the measure will be enforced
"Often the sticking point is: How do we go about enforcing this?" Metro State University criminal justice professor James Densley, cofounder of research initiative The Violence Project, said. "I think it starts to open up a bit of a can of worms, because no one quite knows the best way to go about doing it."
It can be tricky, he said, to decode social media posts by younger people, who could simply be expressing themselves by posting a music video.
"Where this will get tricky is to what extent this is expression and to what extent is this evidence of wrongdoing?" Densley said.
Spokespeople for the social media platforms Facebook, Twitter, 4Chan and Parler didn't immediately respond to requests for comment.
New York should instead consider giving the job to a trained group tasked with figuring out how to best reach out to people online who are showing signs of radicalization or trauma and may need help, Patton said.
"There's a lot of nuance and contextual issues. We speak differently; how we communicate, that could be misunderstood," Patton said. "I'm concerned we don't have the right people or the right tools in place to do this in a way that's useful in actually preventing violence."
Adam Scott Wandt, a public policy professor at the John Jay College of Criminal Justice, said that he supports gun control, but that he worries the New York law could set a precedent for mandatory disclosure of social media activity for people seeking other types of licenses from the state.
New York's law is rushed and vague, said Wandt, who teaches law enforcement personnel how to conduct searches on people through social media.
"I think that what we might have done as a state here in New York is, we may have confirmed their worst fears — that a slippery slope will be created that will slowly reduce their rights to carry guns and allow a bureaucracy to decide, based on unclear criteria, who can have a gun and who cannot," Wandt said. "Which is exactly what the Supreme Court was trying to avoid."
veryGood! (6)
Related
- Meta donates $1 million to Trump’s inauguration fund
- Senator wants Washington Commanders to pay tribute to an old logo that offends many Indigenous
- This woman is wanted in connection to death of Southern California man
- Texas to double $5 billion state fund aimed at expanding the power grid
- Jamie Foxx reps say actor was hit in face by a glass at birthday dinner, needed stitches
- Hunter Biden sues Fox News for publishing nude photos, videos of him in 'mock trial' show
- Biden administration proposes rule for workplaces to address excessive heat
- Oklahoma St RB Ollie Gordon II, who won Doak Walker Award last season, arrested for suspicion of DUI
- A Mississippi company is sentenced for mislabeling cheap seafood as premium local fish
- Sonic joins in on value menu movement: Cheeseburger, wraps, tots priced at $1.99
Ranking
- A South Texas lawmaker’s 15
- 'Guiding Light' actor and model Renauld White dies at 80
- 2 children among 5 killed in small plane crash after New York baseball tournament
- New grand jury transcripts released in Jeffrey Epstein case reveal prosecutors knew about accusations against him
- Trump suggestion that Egypt, Jordan absorb Palestinians from Gaza draws rejections, confusion
- Former Moelis banker seen punching woman is arrested on assault charges
- Woman dies from being pushed into San Francisco-area commuter train
- Team USA Olympic trial ratings show heightened interest for 2024 Games
Recommendation
Are Instagram, Facebook and WhatsApp down? Meta says most issues resolved after outages
Google falling short of important climate target, cites electricity needs of AI
Despite vows of safety from OnlyFans, predators are exploiting kids on the platform
Mistrial declared in Karen Read trial for murder of boyfriend John O'Keefe
Pregnant Kylie Kelce Shares Hilarious Question Her Daughter Asked Jason Kelce Amid Rising Fame
Chick-fil-A now selling waffle fry pool floats and chicken sandwich-shaped towels
Small businesses could find filing for bankruptcy more difficult as government program expires
Woman found dead in Lake Anna, the third body found at the Virginia lake since May